A paid Amazon audit for supplement brands on Amazon US. $1,500 flat. Delivered in five business days. Compliance review, PPC efficiency snapshot, profit architecture analysis, and a priority action plan you can execute with us — or without us.
We don't audit everything — we audit the four things that account for almost all hidden margin loss in supplement brand Amazon accounts. Each section is specific, actionable, and written in operator language, not consultant language.
We read every active listing against Amazon's current supplement category requirements. Claims language. Ingredient flags. Dosage disclosures. Warning language. The things that get listings suppressed on Tuesday afternoons.
Any risk signal we find gets a severity rating and a specific fix recommendation. You leave the audit knowing exactly which listings are one policy update away from a problem, and how to fix them.
We pull 90 days of advertising data and run it through our analysis framework. Which campaigns are profitable, which are bleeding. Which search terms should be promoted, which should be killed. Which campaign structures are leaking efficiency through overlap or bidding mistakes.
You get a prioritized list of the wasted-spend concentration points — the places where a single change recovers the most margin fastest.
Most supplement brands can tell you their revenue by ASIN. Very few can tell you their net margin by ASIN — because the calculation requires FBA fees, ad spend, COGS, and returns stitched together at the unit level. We do it.
The output is a clear table: which ASINs are profit centers, which are break-even, and which are quietly losing money. You'd be surprised how often brands discover they've been losing money on their "best-selling" SKU.
The audit ends with a prioritized action plan — not a list of observations. We rank every finding by margin impact and effort-to-fix, then sequence them into a 30/60/90-day execution order.
Every item includes what to do, how to do it, and what outcome to expect. You can execute this plan with your current team, with us on retainer, or hand it to another agency. It's yours.
We move fast because speed protects margin. Every day an audit sits unfinished is a day you're still losing money to whatever you don't yet know. Here's how the timeline runs.
You pay the audit fee and fill out a short intake form. We send a Seller Central access request and schedule your walkthrough call for day 6.
We run the compliance review, pull 90 days of PPC data, build the profit architecture model, and compile the findings. AI-assisted but senior-reviewed.
The full audit report lands in your inbox. 25–40 pages of specific findings, prioritized recommendations, and the 30/60/90-day execution plan.
60-minute call to walk through every finding together, answer your questions, and discuss what execution looks like. Retainer pricing discussed only if you ask.
Same price regardless of how many ASINs you have or how much revenue you're doing. The work scales, the price doesn't. If we find you're not the right fit during intake, we refund in full before starting.
Most agencies offer "free audits" because the audit isn't the product — the retainer is. The free audit is a sales document. Its job is to create urgency around signing a contract. The analysis is shaped around that goal.
Our audit has a different job. It's a real deliverable. You pay for it because you're getting something genuinely useful — whether you continue with us or not. That changes the incentive. We don't have to find problems that conveniently require our retainer. We just have to find what's actually there.
We've seen what a free audit looks like from the other side. Padded findings. Manufactured urgency. Recommendations conveniently scoped to whatever service the agency wants to sell. That's not a diagnostic — it's a pitch deck in diagnostic clothing.
Paying for the audit makes the audit honest. That's the whole argument.
If your question isn't here, email hello@fussypenguins.com and we'll answer within one business day.
No. The audit is a standalone deliverable. You walk away with a full written report and a 30/60/90-day action plan that you can execute with your current team, with us, or with another agency. Retainer pricing only gets discussed on the walkthrough call if you ask for it.
Most brands who take the audit do end up signing a retainer. That's not because we pressure them — it's because once we've surfaced the findings, execution is the obvious next step. But the decision is yours, not pre-committed.
We only audit supplement brands. If you're in an adjacent category — sports nutrition, beauty-ingestibles, pet supplements — we'll evaluate on a case-by-case basis. For everything else (skincare, food, electronics, apparel, etc.), we'll refund in full and point you toward a specialist in your category.
Yes. We need view-only access to run the analysis. We send a formal Seller Central user access request, you grant the permissions, we conduct the audit, and we remove ourselves automatically at the end if you don't retain us. Access is role-scoped to minimum permissions required.
Full refund if we determine during intake (before the deep work begins) that you're not a fit — either because the category doesn't match or because your situation is one we can't meaningfully help with. Once the audit work begins, the fee is non-refundable since the work has been performed. In practice, refund scenarios are rare because we screen during the discovery call.
Typically within 2–3 business days of order. Once you've paid and sent access, we kick off the audit window — which runs 5 business days to the report delivery, plus day 6 for the walkthrough call. So total elapsed time from payment to walkthrough is typically 7–8 business days.
No. Amazon US only. The supplement policy landscape, customer behavior, and competitive dynamics vary meaningfully across marketplaces. We've chosen to go deep on one rather than shallow on many. If you need Amazon UK, EU, or elsewhere, we're happy to refer you to specialists who operate in those markets.
Free audits are sales tools. Their job is to create urgency around signing a contract, not to give you unbiased analysis. Ours is paid because it's a real deliverable — not shaped around selling you anything. You can read the comparison table above for the specifics. The short version: paying for the audit makes the audit honest.
Fill out the form below. We'll reply within one business day with a secure payment link and the short intake questionnaire. If you'd rather talk first, book a discovery call instead — we're happy either way.